MST
RFQ cartCart

Comparing MPW quotations: normalize fabrication, packaging and test before choosing a price

Planning an MPW project?

Share a non-confidential brief to discuss process fit, shuttle timing, packaging and test scope.

An MPW price is useful only when you know what it buys. A fabrication-only quote and a packaged-sample quote can look similar while leaving very different work for your team. Use this worksheet to compare the same deliverable and expose costs that still need confirmation.

Define a common deliverable first

Write the candidate process and options, design area and billing basis, requested sample quantity and form, test scope, delivery destination, currency and quote validity. Compare technical feasibility separately: matching a price does not make two processes, IP libraries or delivered samples equivalent.
For each supplier response, mark every item included, excluded, or unknown, and identify whether it is charged per project, run, wafer, die, package or shipment.
Scope itemQuestions to resolve before comparison
Fabrication and design areaWhat area/minimum block is billed? What process options and masks are covered?
Access and IPAre tool, PDK or IP rights included, separately licensed or unavailable?
Engineering/NREWhat preparation, review, setup or assembly tooling is charged separately?
Wafer probeWhat measurements, coverage, program and output data are included?
Backgrinding and dicingWhat thickness, singulation, inspection and handling are specified?
PackagingWhat package, materials, assembly quantity and acceptance criteria apply?
Final testWho supplies the program, fixture or board, and what results are delivered?
LogisticsWhat packing, shipping, tax/duty assumptions and delivery terms apply?
UncertaintyWhat happens after failed checks, low yield, a missed run or a design revision?
Public MPW schedules and prices can use different area blocks, process options and additional-service terms. Check the provider's current terms rather than carrying a headline rate into your budget. EUROPRACTICE's schedule and price page (https://europractice-ic.com/schedules-prices-2026/) is one provider-specific example.

Does the minimum MPW area tell me how many chips I will receive?

Die area, billable area and delivered sample quantity are separate quotation items. A minimum-area price alone does not state how many bare dies, assembled devices or electrically accepted samples it includes.
ItemWhat the quotation should state
One dieWidth, height and the boundary used for those dimensions
Billing basisMinimum area or block, allowed increments and treatment of unused space
Sample quantityIncluded count; estimate, target or contractual deliverable; terms for extra samples
Delivered formWafer, diced bare dies, screened dies, assembled packages or devices passing an agreed test
Additional workDicing, packaging, test preparation, test execution and logistics, with scope and exclusions
Some services publish an area rate with a minimum fabrication charge; others publish block sizes. EUROPRACTICE's 2026 schedules and prices (https://europractice-ic.com/schedules-prices-2026/) illustrate these formats; they do not establish another provider's quotation terms.
Ask for a separate line stating the included samples and the price or route for additional quantity. Do not calculate a project total by multiplying die area by requested chip count and a headline MPW area rate unless the provider confirms that billing rule. Do not assume that a minimum-area price includes every requested chip, either.
An assembly quantity is not automatically a count of electrically passing samples. Agree the test scope and acceptance criteria using the wafer probe, final test and bench validation checklist (https://store.mst-sg.com/community/t/39-wafer-probe-final-test-or-bench-validation-a-test-scope) . For an enquiry, include the process, die dimensions, target sample count, delivery form, packaging/test scope and timing requirement.

Worked example: the lower headline price is not the full budget

The following figures are invented teaching values in USD. They are not supplier quotes, MST prices, market benchmarks or delivery/yield commitments. Assume the same hypothetical requested scope for a target of 20 samples, solely to show the arithmetic.
Cost itemExample AExample B
Fabrication10000Included in bundle
Wafer probe600Included in bundle
Dicing300Included in bundle
Assembly1200Included in bundle
Bundle covering the above itemsNot applicable12300
Final test500500
Shipping200200
Total of listed items1280013000
For A: 10000 + 600 + 300 + 1200 + 500 + 200 = 12800 USD. For B: 12300 + 500 + 200 = 13000 USD. Once the listed scope is aligned, A is 200 USD lower. That comparison says nothing about technical suitability, yield or service quality.
These totals still exclude any unconfirmed fixture/board, extra NRE, tax/duty, re-spin or other work. Do not label either number an all-in project budget until those rows are resolved. Do not divide by the requested sample count and call the result a guaranteed cost per passing chip: the deliverable, yield assumptions and acceptance test must be agreed first.

Ask the questions that change the decision

  • Does “samples” mean untested dies, electrically screened dies or packages passing an agreed test?
  • Is sample quantity a target, minimum contractual deliverable or estimate? What remedies apply?
  • Is the proposed run confirmed, and what design acceptance and commercial steps remain?
  • If a report or layout revision changes, which charges and dates must be revalidated?
  • Which items are only estimates, and when will their amounts become binding?
Use the quotation scope comparison tool (https://mst-sg.com/tools/mpw-quote-compare/) to expose missing items. It helps structure a comparison; it does not certify prices, supplier availability or equivalent technical capability.

A project in progress: separating fabrication budget from sample delivery

Status reviewed: 2026-11-15. In an anonymized MPW enquiry handled by MST, a chip design team requested prototype fabrication, packaging and test. MST organized the candidate process, voltage and memory requirements, die-area assumption, design-file readiness, package direction and target sample quantity into a review brief.
A fabrication budget reference was communicated and its scope clarified. Packaging, test and the final sample-delivery scope still needed separate confirmation. The completed work was requirements capture, budget-scope communication and an open-question list; technical acceptance, the final quotation, a production slot and delivery remained pending.
This record describes early project coordination. Tapeout, manufactured samples and test results had not been established. The practical lesson is to request separate written scope for fabrication, sample quantity, packaging, test and delivery before comparing a complete project budget.

HHGrace cooperation and project coordination

For HHGrace MPW enquiries, MST Singapore acts as a non-exclusive customer-access and project-coordination agent for overseas projects. The foundry confirms process eligibility, PDK access, capacity, schedule and quotation for each project. That relationship does not establish acceptance or delivery for the enquiry described above.

Primary references and further reading

Next step: request an MPW quotation-scope review (https://store.mst-sg.com/mpw#mpw-inquiry-form) . Share a non-confidential requirements summary and unresolved scope rows; arrange a private channel before sharing restricted supplier documents. More preparation guides are in the MPW community (https://store.mst-sg.com/community/c/mpw) .
Parts

Replies (0)

No replies yet.

Planning an MPW project?

Share a non-confidential brief to discuss process fit, shuttle timing, packaging and test scope.